Even earlier than I may make out the silhouette of Platform Holly on the foggy horizon, I may see and scent oil. Ripples of iridescent liquid floated on the ocean’s floor, reflecting the cloudy sky. However the oil wasn’t coming from a leak or another failure of the rig. Milton Love, a biologist on the Marine Science Institute on the College of California, Santa Barbara, defined that it was “kind of bubbling up out of the seafloor.” Our boat, lower than two miles from the central California coast, was crusing above a pure oil seep the place the offshore power growth first started.
For hundreds of years the Chumash, an Indigenous group native to the area, recognized these oceanic seeps and their naturally occurring delicate tar, referred to as malak, which washed up on the shore. Sixteenth-century European explorers famous oil off the coast of modern-day Santa Barbara, and within the 1870s the U.S. oil growth reached California. Within the late Nineties the first offshore oil wells on the planet have been drilled from piers off of Summerland Seaside; 60 years later the state’s first offshore oil platform was deployed to drill the Summerland Offshore Subject.
Since then, 34 different oil platforms have been put in alongside the coast, and greater than 12,000 have been put in world wide. These hulking items of infrastructure, nonetheless, have finite lifetimes. Ultimately their oil-producing capacities tail off to the purpose the place it’s not economically viable to function them—that, or there’s a spill. At present 13 of California’s 27 remaining offshore platforms are what’s referred to as shut-in, or not producing oil.
On supporting science journalism
For those who’re having fun with this text, think about supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By buying a subscription you’re serving to to make sure the way forward for impactful tales concerning the discoveries and concepts shaping our world right this moment.
Platform Holly is among the many lifeless platforms awaiting their afterlives. On the time of its set up in 1966, everybody knew a platform located straight over a pure oil and gasoline seep was going to be a hit. And for almost 5 a long time it was. Then, in 2015, a corroded pipeline close to Refugio State Seaside owned by Plains All American Pipeline cracked, spilling 142,800 gallons of crude oil into the Santa Barbara Channel. The spill killed sea lions, pelicans and perch, amongst different creatures; closed fisheries and seashores; and completely severed Platform Holly from its market.
Venoco, the oil firm that owned Holly on the time, was not accountable, but it surely was bankrupted by the occasion. As a result of Holly is positioned inside three miles of the coast, it was transferred into the palms of the California State Lands Fee (SLC) in 2017. The SLC is now accountable for managing the method of decommissioning the platform and figuring out its destiny.
As a result of Holly is already owned by the state, not an oil firm, its transition may illuminate consider the destiny of rigs worldwide based mostly on science, not politics.
In line with platform-decommissioning marketing consultant John Bridges Smith, a former leasing specialist with the Bureau of Ocean Vitality Administration who counts ExxonMobil, ConocoPhillips and Chevron amongst his purchasers, Holly and the eight different platforms whose leases are terminated or expired will likely be decommissioned by the tip of the last decade. Primarily based on the unique contracts between the oil firms and the state and federal governments, which date to the Nineteen Sixties, this implies the constructions should be absolutely eliminated. In December 2023 the Bureau of Security and Environmental Enforcement advisable that every one 23 California platforms standing in federal waters be absolutely eliminated.
Doing so will incur an ideal expense. That’s true in every single place however particularly in California, the place a number of the platforms are in very deep water. In line with one conservative estimate, utterly eradicating all of California’s platforms would value the accountable oil firms $1.5 billion. Smith says these firms would favor to delay that course of for so long as doable. Some environmental teams in California, in the meantime, are pushing to carry them to the speediest timeline.
Platform Holly, positioned off the coast of Santa Barbara, Calif.
Love, who has spent the previous three a long time learning the aquatic life that now calls southern California’s oil platforms house, would favor a 3rd different.
Within the a long time since they have been put in, the metal help constructions of California’s oil platforms have change into vibrant ecosystems remoted from fishing pressures—de facto marine sanctuaries. Moderately than being eliminated, growing old fossil-fuel infrastructure and its serendipitously related habitats may be salvaged within the ocean as state-managed synthetic reefs. Your complete topside—the above-water portion of metal, workplaces and cranes—and shallow part of a rig are eliminated, however a part of the submerged base might stay. A pathway for doing so already exists within the U.S. and has been efficiently adopted 573 instances within the Gulf of Mexico. Comparable examples may be discovered world wide, from Gabon to Australia. As a result of Holly is already owned by the state, not an oil firm, its transition may illuminate consider the destiny of rigs worldwide based mostly on science, not politics.
When an oil platform is decommissioned, the course of goes like this: First, in a section referred to as plugging and abandoning, its oil wells are full of concrete and sealed. Subsequent, scientists conduct an environmental assessment and think about the assorted deserves and dangers of various elimination methods. The outcomes decide a platform’s last resting place, which normally has been in a scrap steel yard. A platform’s help construction known as its jacket—a whole bunch of vertical ft of woven metal that’s affixed to the underside of the ocean. More often than not engineers will use explosives to sever a platform jacket from the seafloor. The metal is then hauled to shore for disposal and recycling. Decommissioning is thought-about full when a platform has been eliminated down to fifteen ft under the mud line and the seafloor has been returned to preplatform circumstances.
Many of the offshore oil platforms which have ever been constructed have been put in within the Gulf of Mexico—greater than 7,000 since 1947. Greater than 5,000 of these have since been eliminated. Within the Eighties oil firms and leisure fishing associations pushed for another consequence that may each be cheaper and assist to bolster struggling fish populations. In 1984 the U.S. Congress handed the Nationwide Fisheries Enhancement Act, offering for the creation of the Nationwide Synthetic Reef Plan, which allowed oil platform operators to donate decommissioned rigs to states as “artificial reefs.”
Within the following years Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Florida and Alabama every handed the mandatory laws and established their very own State Synthetic Reef Applications. These have been, and nonetheless are, funded by oil and gasoline contributions and the curiosity earned on these funds. This system hasn’t changed full removals; between 1987 and 2017 solely 11 % of all decommissioned oil platforms off Louisiana have been partially eliminated. However in deeper waters, the story is totally different: of the 15 constructions decommissioned in depths larger than 400 ft, 14 have been partially eliminated, or “reefed.”
Offshore oil infrastructure in California acts as a nursery for sure fish species.
When a platform is partially eliminated, its topside is taken to shore. To keep away from making a navigational hazard, the primary 80 to 85 ft of its jacket closest to the floor are both introduced ashore or laid alongside the ocean backside. Lastly, the remaining jacket—whether or not it’s 15 ft of metal or a whole bunch—is both left in place or severed from the seafloor and towed to an authorised reefing website. Legal responsibility for the reefed construction will get transferred from the oil firm to the state, and the oil firm donates 50 % of its value financial savings (from doing a partial elimination versus a full elimination) to the state. This course of, colloquially known as rigs-to-reefs, has efficiently bolstered fish populations within the Gulf.
Ann Scarborough Bull, a U.C.S.B. biologist who research the ecology of offshore oil platforms and renewable power installations, labored within the Gulf of Mexico on offshore oil and gasoline regulation for 14 years. She arrived in 1975, when her husband took a job within the extremely worthwhile offshore oil trade. When it got here to grease platform ecology, “the Gulf of Mexico hadn’t been studied,” Bull says. She took a job as a chief scientist for the U.S. Minerals Administration Service, which has since been reorganized into the Bureau of Ocean Vitality Administration, and acquired funding to analysis the communities of fish and invertebrates dwelling beneath the platforms. On her frequent journeys offshore, it turned clear to her that the rig jackets offered habitat that was important to the area’s economic system.
Lutjanus campechanus, generally referred to as the northern purple snapper, is without doubt one of the most incessantly caught species within the Gulf’s leisure fishing trade. An extended-lived apex predator, it’s largely sedentary in its grownup section and restricted to reef habitats. Till the mid-Twentieth century, the main fishing grounds for purple snapper have been off the western coast of Florida and within the waters south of the Florida Panhandle.
Simply as populations within the fish’s historic vary have been being depleted by overfishing and trawling, purple snapper started to shift and increase west throughout everything of the Gulf. Hundreds of oil platforms have been being put in throughout the northwestern and north-central Gulf. Many years of analysis have proven that with pure reefs few and much between, purple snapper have been utilizing the oil platforms as a sort of outpost, which allowed their inhabitants dimension to increase considerably.
Think about the Empire State Constructing extending up from the ocean ground, blossoming with mussels and scallops and sea anemones, offering meals to legions of fish.
As drilling operations multiplied, business and leisure reef-fishing industries grew in tandem. Surveys from the early Eighties indicated that one quarter of fishing journeys have been related to oil and gasoline constructions. “This whole society in the Gulf of Mexico grew up with two ways to make a living: one, be a fisherman, and the other, be connected with oil and gas,” Bull says.
In 2001 Bull moved again to her native California, and he or she arrived at U.C.S.B. in 2016. Her expertise learning the state’s platforms and coming to know the encompassing politics has proven her that the variations in platform technique between California and Louisiana are multifold. “There are factions, especially in Santa Barbara, that absolutely despise oil and gas companies,” Bull says. This animosity, she explains, makes the rigs-to-reefs course of a more durable promote.
It’s not unwarranted. On January 28, 1969, a blowout at Union Oil’s Platform A within the Santa Barbara Channel spilled 100,000 barrels of crude oil into the Pacific Ocean. Black tar coated seashores for dozens of miles and killed hundreds of birds and marine mammals. On the time, it was the biggest oil spill in U.S. historical past.
The spill prompted the primary Earth Day and the creation of the U.S. Environmental Safety Company. It additionally spawned quite a few environmental nonprofits within the Santa Barbara area, together with Get Oil Out! and the Environmental Protection Middle. Growth of latest oil fields off the coast of California halted and didn’t resume till 1982.
Then California’s first decommissionings started. In 1988 Texaco efficiently eliminated Platforms Helen and Herman. In 1996 Chevron eliminated Platforms Hope, Heidi, Hilda and Hazel from the Santa Barbara coast—however not utterly. The cuttings piles—gigantic mounds of rock particles, mud, and different hydrocarbon detritus discharged by the drilling course of—beneath all 4 platforms have been allowed to stay.
Linda Krop, now chief counsel for the Environmental Protection Middle, was then a regulation clerk with the group. The group wasn’t too blissful that Chevron had seemingly gotten across the obligations of its unique contracts, which required full elimination of its platforms and restoration of the native setting to its pure situation.
“I just think it’s criminal to kill huge numbers of animals because they settled on a piece of steel instead of a rock.” —Milton Love, biologist
Within the almost three a long time since, Krop has labored as an legal professional holding oil firms accountable for his or her environmentally damaging actions. She had her biggest court docket victory in 2016, reaching the termination of 40 federal oil leases offshore. Krop is firmly in opposition to the prospect of reefing off California. “The fish are going to be fine if the platforms go away,” she says. “They’re not going to disappear.”
In July 2023 I visited Holly with Milton Love on an particularly foggy morning. After a 30-minute boat journey from the Santa Barbara Harbor, its skeletal define started to emerge from the mist. From a distance Holly resembled a cranium with barred enamel and low, hole eyes, however up shut it was an eight-story scaffolding of metal beams, pylons and outdated delivery containers.
Holly hasn’t produced oil for a decade, however the whirring and beeping of mills and cranes was nonetheless too loud to talk over. Folks in building vests milled concerning the higher decks, ostensibly monitoring the wells’ latest plugging process and shoring up the platform. Brown sea lions have been flinging themselves from the ocean onto the platform’s decrease decks, howling and jostling for area. Love informed me that what we have been seeing was solely a small piece of the motion. The actual story, he mentioned, was hidden under the waterline, the place the mechanical noise dims and is changed by the crackle of shrimp and fish nibbling on the reef.
The platform jackets are coated in hundreds of thousands of organisms and supply habitat for hundreds of fish. A few of California’s 27 platforms are comparatively small; Holly stands in solely 211 ft of water. Others, such because the Exxon-constructed Concord, stand in depths as much as 1,198 ft. Think about the Empire State Constructing extending up from the ocean ground, blossoming with mussels and scallops and sea anemones, offering meals to legions of fish. In line with a 2014 paper co-authored by Love, these platforms are among the many best marine fish habitats on the planet and, per cubic meter of seafloor, are extra productive than any pure reef.
In 2019 the Gulf leisure fishing group took greater than 50 million journeys and caught 332.5 million fish. However leisure fishing off the coast of California is nowhere close to as massive. And due to the greater than 120,000 acres of pure rock reef alongside the state’s coast and Channel Islands, the quantity of habitat space generated by the rigs doesn’t considerably alter the full regional habitat space or improve the carrying capability of the fish inhabitants. In distinction, the Gulf platforms contribute 30 % of their area’s complete “reef” habitat space.
Love argues that California’s platform ecosystems are important for various causes. After ending his Ph.D. and touchdown at U.C.S.B. as a analysis biologist, Love acquired funding from the Nationwide Organic Survey; he wrote a e-book referred to as The Rockfishes of the Northeast Pacific and got down to examine how oil platforms functioned as fish habitats. “Most of the money has always been from the federal government,” Love says. However a “small percentage” got here from Chevron and ExxonMobil.
Love’s early work laid the foundations for others to analysis the constructions as properly. In a 2014 examine, quantitative marine ecologist Jeremy T. Claisse, now at California State Polytechnic College, Pomona, and his colleagues revealed that alongside the coast of southern California, jacket habitats don’t simply help hundreds of thousands of tunicates, barnacles, rock scallops and shrimp; they are often websites of fish manufacturing. Meaning many fishes dwelling on and across the legs develop up there and should both spend everything of their lives at one platform or journey elsewhere, bolstering fish populations close by.
Sea anemones reside on the shell mounds that kind below the platform legs.
Bocaccio and cowcod rockfish of southern California’s pure reefs are economically essential and at one level have been thought-about overfished. In 2006 Love discovered that California’s offshore oil platforms contribute 20 % of the younger bocaccio rockfish that survive annually throughout the species’ complete geographic vary, which stretches from Alaska to Baja California. The platforms function basically as nurseries, he says, incubating the subsequent technology.
Mussels dominate the platform jacket within the first 40 ft of water, forming three-inch crusts across the submerged legs and beams. Barnacles and bivalves prolong even deeper. When these creatures die or are dislodged by a storm, they sink to the ft of the gargantuan constructions and kind shell mounds as much as 220 ft in diameter and rising upward of 20 ft from the seafloor. Each among the many decaying shell mounds and all through the crisscrossing beams of the platforms’ midwater sections, juvenile rockfish of the area proliferate.
Trapped inside these shell mounds, nonetheless, are the piles of poisonous drill cuttings. Till the late Nineteen Seventies, regulation to correctly eliminate cuttings was pretty unfastened, and operators would typically deposit the particles on the seafloor. In a 2001 examine, floor sediments from the shell mound of Platform Hazel, put in in 1958, have been discovered to be deadly to 50 % of examined shrimp inside 96 hours of publicity. Not too long ago put in platforms don’t seem to have the identical drawback, maybe as a result of most cuttings should be hauled to shore. In a single examine, cuttings piles under platforms put in earlier than stricter regulation have been discovered to include 100 instances extra risky natural compounds than a more moderen platform, Gina, put in in 1980.
Love and his colleagues needed to know if the contamination from cuttings prolonged to the water column across the shell mound. In 2013 they printed a paper that discovered California’s platforms—no matter age—weren’t contaminating their related fish populations. “We looked at fishes that live around platforms—not just Holly but throughout southern California—and compared the heavy metal concentrations with fishes of the same species on nearby natural reefs,” he says. “There was no statistical difference between what we saw.”
Nonetheless, folks like Krop on the Environmental Protection Middle will not be satisfied any oil infrastructure must be allowed to remain within the ocean. “If we need to build some [more] artificial reefs, then let’s do it the right way,” she says. California has been constructing its personal synthetic reefs since 1958, when the state’s Division of Fish and Wildlife positioned 20 car our bodies within the waters of Paradise Cove off Malibu. Such synthetic reefs are usually unfold over many acres in comparatively shallow waters. Platform jacket reefs, in distinction, will not be even technically synthetic reefs and exist as habitats of utmost vertical complexity and dimension. They’re smaller in space but extra productive on common.
In 2003 Mark Carr of the College of California, Santa Cruz, wrote that there are few pure rock reefs on the depths of the California oil platforms and none with comparable bodily traits. If the aim is to contribute to general reef space, their worth is “minuscule.” If, nonetheless, the intent is to protect their distinctive habitats, their worth is “100 percent.”
Love has a extra irreverent perspective on their worth. “As a biologist, I just give people facts,” he says. “But I have my own view as a citizen, which is: I just think it’s criminal to kill huge numbers of animals because they settled on a piece of steel instead of a rock.”
Many international locations world wide are arising on the decommissioning of their platforms for the primary time. In line with Amber Sparks of Blue Latitudes, an organization that consults for governments worldwide relating to the environmental results of their platform-decommissioning practices, there may be no worldwide commonplace for a way an oil platform must be reefed.
Globally, the method is commonly advert hoc. Off the coast of Gabon, for example, high-biodiversity habitats beneath greater than 40 lively oil platforms are included in a system of marine nationwide parks. In Malaysia, an oil platform has been transformed right into a resort for scuba divers. With the help of Chevron, Thailand established a synthetic reef program and reefed seven platforms close to Koh Pha-Ngan in 2020. In waters off the U.Okay., 5 platforms have been authorised for partial elimination, however no full platform jacket has been reefed, and no rigs-to-reef program exists. A 2017 examine evaluated the opportunity of remodeling one U.Okay. rig right into a hub for harvesting wave power.
When a decommissioned platform is eliminated, so, too, goes habitat space for sea lions and sure fish species.
In line with Francis Norman, managing director of the nonprofit Middle of Decommissioning Australia, there may be giant demand from leisure fishing communities for synthetic reefs—at the least off the coast of Western Australia, the place greater than 40 platforms are stationed in shallow waters. However within the jap state of Victoria, 23 Exxon platforms within the Bass Strait are in depths as much as 525 ft—these constructions are too removed from land to be seen over the horizon and will not be fished due to tough water circumstances.
Norman says Australia doesn’t have an official rigs-to-reef program, however in 2023 Exxon utilized for permits to partially take away 13 of its platforms. The corporate, he says, withdrew its utility this summer season after a wave of media reviews featured criticism of partial elimination.
As of August 2024, all of Holly’s 30 wells have been absolutely plugged and deserted. Jennifer Lucchesi, government director of the California State Lands Fee, says the ability is being “hardened” so it received’t want 24-hour staffing because it strikes into “caretaker” standing. Now research of Holly’s subsurface biology are trying on the platform’s results on its native marine setting to tell the creation of an environmental affect report, which can assessment the probably internet outcomes of full elimination versus partial elimination versus no motion. The “biological study” part is being ready by Love, Bull and their colleagues at U.C.S.B.
Oil firms are excited by platform reefing due to cash, not fish. Partial elimination is much cheaper than full elimination. Reefing the California platforms as an alternative of eradicating them would internet the businesses a financial savings of $150 million and generate $600 million for the state. (Precise prices and financial savings for elimination are prone to exceed these projections by at the least an element of 4.) Nonetheless, not a single California platform operator has utilized to start the rigs-to-reef course of. Smith believes the hesitancy outcomes from variations in coverage. Laws within the Gulf States asks for 50 % of an oil firm’s value financial savings to be paid to a state normally; in California, it’s 80 %. And whereas within the Gulf legal responsibility transfers to the state, in California it basically stays with the accountable oil firm. Earlier makes an attempt, in 2015 and 2017, to amend the laws in California failed. Krop says teams like hers “would not support making the state liable,” and Smith says that may make reefing “unworkable” for the oil firms. When approached for a remark, Chevron wrote: “We are still finalizing our decision on this issue.”
Smith believes the more than likely consequence for California’s growing old offshore infrastructure will likely be not full elimination or partial elimination however indefinite delays. Operators are alleged to submit decommissioning plans two years earlier than a lease ends, however operators for six offshore platforms whose leases led to 2015 nonetheless haven’t adopted via.
Oil platforms have been designed to be productive for 20 to 30 years, however some are nonetheless producing oil after 45 years. Nobody is aware of how lengthy they may stand. In a single state of affairs, upkeep might not be correctly stored up. This isn’t exhausting to think about: Platform Holly fell right into a state of disrepair following its operator’s chapter, and ExxonMobil, a previous operator, paid hundreds of thousands to refurbish the platform so it may help the gear required to plug and abandon its dormant wells.
In a soon-to-be-published paper on the subject of delay, Smith discusses a worst-case state of affairs through which poor upkeep and corroded metal trigger a platform to break down throughout an earthquake or storm. A pile of metal legs, crossbeams and submerged topside workplaces would relaxation like a shipwreck on the seafloor. Many of the midwater organisms could be gone, as would these related to the prolonged vertical water column. However Love says organisms related to advanced backside habitats would maybe flourish. Rockfish and lingcod would swim across the jagged, anemone-covered items of damaged platform legs and rusted metal, previous scurrying crabs, exploring their reconfigured house.
In one other world, you may see oil firms maintaining with upkeep indefinitely. To stop the metal legs from rusting and collapsing, they may proceed making use of zinc anodes to the metal bars, permitting the zinc to rust as an alternative of the legs. “The marine habitat will change with climate change, of course, as everywhere will,” Love says. However the sea lions would stick round on the decrease decks, as would the blacksmith damselfish within the shallow waters. The platforms’ topsides, steadfast off the Santa Barbara coast, could be a reminder of an oil-ridden previous.
